Influence vs Manipulation: Navigating a Thin Line

by | 17 Dec 2023 | Behavioural Science, Leadership, Sales Psychology

Let’s dive into a topic that’s a game-changer in the business world but often gets pushed aside — the razor-thin line between influence and manipulation. These two concepts may look similar, but believe me, they’re as different as day and night in their core principles and impact. I’ve ridden the business rollercoaster for years and witnessed firsthand how both tactics play out in various business scenarios. It’s all about the intent behind your actions and how transparent you are in your approach. In this article, we explore the subtle yet significant differences between influence and manipulation, shedding light on how business professionals can harness the power of persuasion responsibly.

The Real Deal About Influence in Business

Influence — it’s a term that gets thrown around a lot. But what does it really mean? It’s not just about getting people to do what you want. It’s about guiding others with a blend of persuasion, respect, and integrity. This is crucial in business, where the quality of relationships can make or break deals and determine the longevity of partnerships. 

Influence draws on principles rooted in behavioural science, emphasising the power of persuasion and collaboration. At its core, influence seeks to guide individuals or groups toward a shared goal by aligning interests and fostering a sense of unity. Successful influencers in business understand the psychology of decision-making, leveraging principles such as reciprocity, social proof, and authority to create positive outcomes.

I’ve seen true influence in action, and let me tell you, it’s powerful.

Ethical Influence: My Experience and Insights on Persuasion

Throughout my career, I’ve seen ethical influence work wonders. In sales, it’s about creating real value for your clients. It’s understanding their pain points and offering solutions that genuinely meet their needs. As a leader, it involves guiding your team with a vision that resonates with them, fostering a culture of collaboration and mutual respect.

Persuasion is a collaborative process that respects the autonomy of individuals. Ethical persuaders provide relevant information, allowing individuals to make decisions that align with their values and goals. This approach not only builds trust but also contributes to the development of long-lasting partnerships in the business ecosystem.

These are invaluable assets in the business world that you just can’t buy.

The Sneaky World of Manipulation

Now, let’s switch gears and talk about manipulation. This is the darker side of persuasion. It’s about achieving quick, often self-serving goals at the expense of others. It could be overstating a product’s capabilities, using high-pressure sales tactics, or misleading marketing strategies.

Manipulation manifests as coercive power plays and creates a culture of fear to achieve compliance. While these tactics might yield immediate results, they are short-lived and often lead to a detrimental erosion of trust and a distorted perception of reality.

How to Spot the Difference

Differentiating between influence and manipulation is critical. Ethical influencers are transparent about their objectives and seek mutually beneficial outcomes. They respect the decision-making process of their clients or team members and use their authority or expertise to guide them. Ethical influence fosters a positive environment where clients and team members feel valued and understood. This approach leads to repeat business, referrals, and a strong brand image.

Manipulators, on the other hand, often have hidden agendas. It’s all about personal gain. They may withhold information, use misleading data, or exploit emotional vulnerabilities to achieve their goals. Manipulative tactics may lead to immediate gains but at the cost of long-term damage to relationships and reputation.

There are, unfortunately, ethical repercussions.

Empathy: The Golden Key in Business Influence

Empathy is not just a nice-to-have; it’s a must-have in this world. It’s about genuinely putting yourself in your client’s shoes. When you operate from a place of empathy, you’re not just another person trying to make a sale or get a task done; you’re a partner. And that’s where the true influence lies.

Influence as a Lifestyle in Business

Practising ethical influence means building a world of business that’s both profitable and principled. It’s about creating a legacy of integrity, trust and mutual respect. Every interaction, every deal, every leadership decision is an opportunity to choose influence over manipulation.

In my journey, I’ve learned that this approach not only leads to business success but also to personal fulfilment. There’s a deep satisfaction in knowing that your success isn’t built on shortcuts or shady tactics but on real, human connections.


In the intricate dance of business dynamics, understanding the nuances of influence and manipulation is essential for creating a sustainable and ethical organisational culture. Behavioural science provides valuable insights into the psychological underpinnings of decision-making, allowing businesses to navigate the ethical waters with clarity and purpose.

I would like to emphasise that whether you’re a budding entrepreneur, a seasoned executive, or somewhere in between, the path of ethical influence is always open. It’s about being mindful of how we interact with others, grounding our actions in empathy and respect. By choosing ethical influence, we’re not just doing the right thing; we’re shaping a business landscape that’s more trustworthy, respectful and ultimately more successful. And that is the true art of influence.

Join more than 10k subscribers and learn how to apply Behavioural Science and Psychology to your business.

Subscribe to our newsletter “The SCOOP”


Dr Leanne Elich PhD. GAICD. CEO, Leanne Elich Consulting

Leanne Elich is a Sales Psychology & Business Strategist with expertise in Neuroscience and Behavioural Science sales techniques. Leanne and her team work with individuals, teams and organisations to create powerful sales strategies to ethically influence consumer behaviour and create visibility in a busy market.